Cases

Franco v. San Juan County
Vindicating the Right to Earn an Honest Living in the Evergreen State

 
 

For more than 30 years, Gary Franco has earned a living as a vendor who sells fresh, Washington-grown produce in and around San Juan County.  But government officials have now passed a law designed to force vendors like Gary out of business.

Too often, government officials are more concerned about protecting special interests than they are the rights of entrepreneurs.  That’s the case in San Juan County, Wash., where the County council recently passed a law designed to shut down hardworking entrepreneur Gary Franco, a longtime produce vendor.

The ordinance, passed at the behest of politically connected brick-and-mortar businesses, requires vendors to obtain a government permit and pay $50 per day for the right to earn their living.  Were that not bad enough, to obtain the permit, the vendors must receive the consent of competing brick-and-mortar businesses.  In other words, the ordinance gives business owners the right to veto their competition.

While the County maintained that requiring a permit to vend was necessary to protect the public health and safety, it didn’t force all vendors to obtain a permit.  Rather, it carved out exemptions for its own favored categories of vendors—for example, farmers who sell their own produce; ice cream trucks; and nonprofit and charitable groups, such as the Lions Club or Kiwanis.  Vendors like Gary pose no more of problem than these favored, exempt vendors, yet they are still required to pay the government and obtain the blessing of their competitors in order to earn an honest living.    

That is about to change.  Assisted by the Institute for Justice Washington Chapter, Gary is challenging San Juan’s ordinance in order to vindicate the right of all Washingtonians to earn an honest living free of the kind of economic protectionism behind San Juan’s unconstitutional ordinance.  

Essential Background

 

Images

Backgrounder: Local Entrepreneur & Institute for Justice Challenge San Juan County Vending Ordinance
 

 

Client Photo

 

Client Video - none available

Launch Release: Entrepreneur Files Constitutional Lawsuit Against San Juan County (September 16, 2009)    
   


 

Legal Briefs and Decisions

 

IJ Complaint filed September 16, 2009

 

 



Case Timeline

Filed Lawsuit: 


September 16, 2009

Court Filed:

 

San Juan County Superior Court

Decision(s):

 

none available

     

Next Key Date:


TBD

   

 

     

Additional Releases

 

Maps, Charts and Facts

none available

 

none available

 

 


 
   
   

Op-eds, News Articles and Links

    Article: Rotten Law Spoiling Produce Entrepreneur's Right to Earn an Honest Living Liberty & Law (December 2009)
   

Article: Farmer Sues Over County Permit Capital Press, Sep 25 2009

 
 

Article: Peddling Ordinance Lawsuit Filed The Island Guardian, Sep 17 2009

 
  Article: Lopez farmer sues San Juan County over ordinance requiring vendor permits; says law is discriminatory, unconstitutional San Juan Journal, Sep 16 2009
 
  Article: Did You Get Your Competitor's Permission to Open that Business? Reason Hit & Run, Sep 16 2009
     

Share/Save/Bookmark

Institute for Justice
901 N. Glebe Road, Suite 900
Arlington, VA 22203
Tel 703.682.9320, Fax 703.682.9321
© 1997-2010