Maryland Funeral Homes

Brown v. Hovatter
Putting Maryland's Funeral Home Cartel To Rest

 IJ Client Charles S. Brown

 

All Charles S. Brown wants is the chance to offer consumers the best service a funeral home can at the best price. But the State of Maryland is standing in his way.

Brown owns Rest Haven Cemetery in Hagerstown, Md., and runs it with his wife Pat and their son Eric. Charles wants to own the funeral home he built in order to provide additional revenue to care for the gravesites in his cemetery when the cemetery itself is full.

The State of Maryland arbitrarily restricts who can own a funeral home. In Maryland, only licensed funeral directors and a handful of politically favored corporations and individuals may own a funeral home. Becoming a licensed funeral director takes two years of study and thousands of dollars. Among the many requirements of a mortuary science degree is learning how to embalm corpses. As a result, consumers pay more than they otherwise would, and opportunities for would-be entrepreneurs are blocked. These are among the reasons why the Institute for Justice filed a federal lawsuit seeking to break up the government-imposed cartel.

Maryland’s law is a racket designed to protect the state’s funeral cartel from competition, and that’s not a valid use of government authority.  Federal District Judge Richard D. Bennett agreed, declaring the law unconstitutional and describing it as “the most blatantly anti-competitive state funeral regulation in the nation.”  But the Fourth Circuit reversed Judge Bennett on the grounds that the movement of investment capital and profits across state lines was not “interstate commerce” within the meaning of the Constitution.  Unfortunately, the Supreme Court declined to review that obviously erroneous ruling even though it was in direct conflict with Supreme Court precedent and with case law in several other circuits.  As a result, Charles Brown and his fellow plaintiffs will have to go back to the same state legislature that refused to change this exploitative, unjust law for more than 15 years, and hope that this time legislators will finally choose to put the interests of hard-working consumers and entrepreneurs ahead of the Maryland funeral cartel.


Essential Background

Images

Background on this case

Client Photo

Latest Release: IJ Appeals Maryland Funeral Home Case To U.S. Supreme Court (August 24, 2009)

Client Photos - case launch

Client Video - none available

 

Launch Release: Putting Maryland’s Funeral Home Cartel To Rest (March 1, 2006)

Legal Briefs and Decisions

Court's opinion denying Maryland's motion to dismiss

 

Cert Petition (August 2009)

Case Timeline

Filed Lawsuit:

 

March 1, 2006

Court Filed:

 

U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland

Status:

 

Cross-Motions for Summary Judgment Filed April 24, 2007

Summary Judgment Briefing completed June 8, 2007

Next Key Date:

 

Awaiting Decision

 

Additional Releases

Maps, Charts and Fact

Release: Fourth Circuit Hears Case on Anti-Competitive Funeral Home Cartel (January 27, 2009)

none available

 Release: Maryland Ban on Corporate Ownership of Funeral Homes Struck Down as Unconstitutional (October 17, 2007)

 

 

Release: Funeral Home Entrepreneurs Have Their Day in Court (September 10, 2007) 

 

Op-eds, News Articles and Links

Article: IJ Appeals Two Cases to U.S. Supreme Court - Burying Maryland's Funeral Home Cartel Liberty & Law (October 2009)
Release: Funeral Home Entrepreneurs Score a Victory Federal Court Denies Motion to Dismiss Maryland Economic Liberty Case (October 11, 2006)

Article: It doesn’t take an expert to tell you a government-imposed cartel is bad. Or does it? Liberty & Law (October 2007)

Editorial: State must ensure level playing field for business Baltimore Examiner
October 18, 2006

Article: Burying the Competition: IJ Takes on Maryland's Funeral Home Cartel, Liberty & Law (April 2006)

Article: Funeral directors sue state board Gazette Newspapers
March 3, 2006

Article: Suit challenges Maryland's funeral home law Associated Press
March 1, 2006


Email Address
Please enter a valid email address
Share

Institute for Justice
901 N. Glebe Road, Suite 900
Arlington, VA 22203
Tel 703.682.9320, Fax 703.682.9321
© 1997-2014